Butterfly Garaydia ALC vs Stiga Carbonado 45: Which Should You Buy?
| Butterfly Garaydia ALC | Stiga Carbonado 45 | |
|---|---|---|
| Our rating | 8.5/10 | 8.4/10 |
| control | — | — |
| feel | Crisp, hard and stiff with a direct, low-vibration touch and a notably low throw arc | Moderately stiff with deep reverberating vibrations; more wood-like dwell than typical carbon blades; high throw angle |
| handle | FL | Straight/Flared/Anatomic (coal-grey dyed wood) |
| plies | 5-ply total: 3 wood + 2 Arylate-Carbon (ALC) layers, with an outer carbon construction under a Japanese hinoki surface ply | 7-ply with TeXtreme carbon (5 wood + 2 carbon at 45-degree angle) |
| speed | OFF | OFF |
| spin | — | — |
| thickness_mm | 6.9 | 5.7mm |
| type | OFF | — |
| weight_g | 83 | 85-91g |
We may earn a commission from links on this page. Learn more.
Butterfly Garaydia ALC (8.5) is a stiff, low-throw arylate-carbon blade with crisp direct feel, almost vibration-free contact, outstanding near-table control, and 83-gram manageable weight. Stiga Carbonado 45 (8.4) is a TeXtreme carbon blade delivering wood-like feel with informative vibrations, high throw angle aiding heavy topspin loops, excellent short game, and balanced 85-91 gram weight. Both are OFF speed but emphasize different playing characteristics.
Garaydia ALC excels at blocking, flicking, and counter-topspin with minimal ball feedback and very low arc; Carbonado 45 prioritizes loop-dominant spin-heavy play with communicative feedback and higher throw. Garaydia ALC demands precise technique to reach maximum speed away from table; Carbonado 45 requires extra physical effort for mid-distance power but excels at close-table short game. Garaydia ALC is stiffer and more damped; Carbonado 45 offers more vibration feedback. Both are discontinued. Choose Garaydia ALC for ultimate near-table control; Carbonado 45 for communicative loop-dominant play.
FAQ
Which has more feel and feedback?
Stiga Carbonado 45 delivers informative vibrations; Garaydia ALC is almost vibration-free with minimal feedback.
Which aids heavy topspin loops?
Carbonado 45’s high throw angle aids heavy loops; Garaydia ALC’s very low throw excels at blocks and flicks.
Which is better for short game?
Carbonado 45 excels at short game and drop shots; Garaydia ALC is strong but less specialized.
Which requires more physical effort away from table?
Garaydia ALC can feel weak away from table without strong footwork; Carbonado 45 requires extra effort for mid-distance power.