Donic Waldner Allplay vs Stiga Carbonado 145: Which Should You Buy?
| Donic Waldner Allplay | Stiga Carbonado 145 | |
|---|---|---|
| Our rating | 8.2/10 | 8.4/10 |
| feel | Soft and forgiving with good dwell time, slight stiffness at sweet spot | stiff, direct and rather linear with a large sweet spot, but the very thin TeXtreme layers keep the vibration close to a 5-ply all-wood blade |
| handle | FL (flared), classic dark-brown wood | FL/ST (also offered as Legend and penhold) |
| plies | 5-ply all wood (Limba-Ayous-Ayous-Ayous-Limba) | 5 wood plus 2 TeXtreme carbon (5+2 composite) with the carbon fibers laid at a 45 degree angle for torsional bendability |
| speed | ALL | OFF+ |
| thickness_mm | 5.4-5.6 mm | 5.7 |
| weight_g | approx 85-87 g | 85 |
We may earn a commission from links on this page. Learn more.
This is a match between philosophies. The Donic Waldner Allplay is a soft, all-wood control tool rated 8.2; the Stiga Carbonado 145 is a stiff, fast carbon blade rated 8.4 designed for aggressive two-wing attackers. Pick the Donic if you’re building technique and need forgiving feedback. Pick the Carbonado 145 if you’re already competent and want a stiff, mid-distance power engine with wood-like vibration and a large sweet spot.
The Donic rewards consistency and patience. The Carbonado rewards aggression and precise timing. They serve entirely different player profiles and play styles.
FAQ
Which is faster?
Stiga Carbonado 145 by far (OFF+ vs ALL)—it’s built for offense from mid-distance. The Donic is a near-table blade.
Which is more forgiving?
Donic Waldner Allplay. The Carbonado 145 is demanding and unforgiving for players still building consistency.
Can I learn on the Carbonado 145?
Not easily. It’s intermediate-to-advanced. The Donic is explicitly designed for beginners and intermediate players.
Is the Carbonado 145 still in production?
No, it’s now discontinued and hard to source new. The Donic remains in regular production.