Butterfly Timo Boll Spirit vs Stiga Carbonado 45: Which Should You Buy?
| Butterfly Timo Boll Spirit | Stiga Carbonado 45 | |
|---|---|---|
| Our rating | 9.0/10 | 8.4/10 |
| feel | Medium and offensive with notable flex and long dwell, crisp but forgiving for a carbon blade | Moderately stiff with deep reverberating vibrations; more wood-like dwell than typical carbon blades; high throw angle |
| handle | FL / ST / AN | Straight/Flared/Anatomic (coal-grey dyed wood) |
| plies | 5 wood plies plus 2 arylate-carbon outer layers (5W and 2 ALC) | 7-ply with TeXtreme carbon (5 wood + 2 carbon at 45-degree angle) |
| speed | OFF | OFF |
| thickness_mm | 5.7 | 5.7mm |
| weight_g | 87 | 85-91g |
We may earn a commission from links on this page. Learn more.
The Butterfly Timo Boll Spirit (9.0) is a premium all-round offensive carbon blade with long dwell time, forgiving soft touch, and outstanding ball feel that has aged exceptionally well over two decades. The Stiga Carbonado 45 (8.4) emphasizes wood-like feel with informative vibrations, a high throw angle optimized for heavy topspin loops, and consistency that appeals to loop-dominant, spin-heavy players.
Both play at OFF speed and weigh similar amounts (87g and 85-91g), but differ fundamentally in philosophy. Timo Boll Spirit’s long dwell makes heavy, controllable topspin easy while maintaining excellent blocking and counterplay—a genuinely versatile blade rated 9.0 for its all-round capability. Carbonado 45 prioritizes loop specialists with its high throw angle and outstanding short game but lacks pace on smashes and requires extra physical effort for power shots from mid-distance. Timo Boll Spirit’s genuine OFF speed can overwhelm players with weak technique; Carbonado 45 is deliberately slower than most carbon blades, trading speed for consistency and feeling. Both are endorsed by elite players (Timo Boll Spirit’s legacy is twenty years of recommendation; Carbonado 45 is endorsed by top Chinese women’s national team players).
Select Timo Boll Spirit if you want a versatile offensive blade excelling at looping, blocking, and combination play with premium feel. Select Carbonado 45 if you are loop-dominant, play close to the table, and prioritize spin, control, and consistency over raw speed.
FAQ
Which is better for looping and topspin?
Timo Boll Spirit makes heavy, controllable topspin easy. Carbonado 45’s high throw angle aids heavy topspin loops and is designed for spin-heavy styles.
Which is more versatile?
Timo Boll Spirit is versatile across looping, counter-hitting, and combination styles. Carbonado 45 is optimized for loop-dominant game styles.
Which has better short game and control?
Both excel at short game and consistency, but Timo Boll Spirit adds versatility for blocking and counterplay. Carbonado 45 is outstanding for short game and drop shots.
Which is better value?
Carbonado 45 offers exceptional value. Timo Boll Spirit commands premium pricing.
Which is faster?
Both are OFF speed, but Timo Boll Spirit’s genuine OFF speed delivers deeper power. Carbonado 45 is slower than most carbon blades.