Butterfly Lin Gaoyuan ALC vs Stiga Emerald VPS V: Which Should You Buy?
| Butterfly Lin Gaoyuan ALC | Stiga Emerald VPS V | |
|---|---|---|
| Our rating | 8.7/10 | 8.3/10 |
| feel | Soft — flexible ALC gives a more wood-like feel than other carbon blades; high dwell time | Stiff, hard outer surface with medium throw angle and large sweet spot |
| handle | Shakehand (FL, AN, ST options); shorter anatomic handle than Viscaria | Flared (FL), also available in ST and Chinese pen |
| plies | 5 wood + 2 arylate-carbon (ALC) — 7-ply construction with koto outer layers and inner arylate-carbon fiber | 5-ply all wood (Ebenholz/dark outer, VPS-treated middle veneers) |
| speed | OFF (Butterfly rates Reaction 118, mid-fast; equivalent to OFF/OFF+ class) | OFF+ |
| thickness_mm | 5.7mm | 6.2 |
| weight_g | 84-87g typical (Butterfly spec approx 87g) | 98 |
We may earn a commission from links on this page. Learn more.
The Butterfly Lin Gaoyuan ALC (8.7 rating) is an OFF-speed arylate-carbon blade with soft, flexible feel and large head. Its impressive spin generation, control at distance, and forgiving dwell suit advanced attackers transitioning from wood who value versatility and feedback. Discontinued production and shorter anatomic handle limit practical availability.
The Stiga Emerald VPS V (8.3 rating) is a five-ply all-wood blade with VPS-treated veneers for enhanced consistency and dwell. It delivers OFF-plus speed and large sweet spot but with stiff construction that punishes weak technique, lower control scores than all-rounders, premium pricing, and near-98-gram weight causing fatigue.
Both suit advanced players, but the Lin GA is more forgiving and versatile across play types, while the Emerald demands consistent, powerful technique for maximum effectiveness. The Lin GA offers carbon speed with dwell; the Emerald offers all-wood speed with stiffness. Choose Lin GA for versatility; choose Emerald for pure all-wood feel with maximum speed.
FAQ
Which blade is heavier?
The Stiga Emerald at around 98 grams is significantly heavier than the Lin GA at 84-87 grams, potentially causing fatigue in long sessions.
Which blade is better for advanced attackers?
Both suit advanced attackers but differently. The Lin GA is more versatile and forgiving; the Emerald is more specialized for powerful, consistent topspin.
What does VPS treatment do?
VPS treatment of middle veneers improves consistency and extends dwell time during topspin loops, helping generate heavy spin.
Which blade should I choose?
Choose the Lin GA if you want carbon speed with forgiving dwell and versatility. Choose the Emerald if you can swing powerfully and prefer all-wood feel.