Butterfly Maze Magic vs Donic Appelgren Allplay: Which Should You Buy?
| Butterfly Maze Magic | Donic Appelgren Allplay | |
|---|---|---|
| Our rating | 8.3/10 | 8.3/10 |
| feel | medium softness, enveloping dwell, good vibration feedback | medium, controlled |
| handle | AN / FL / ST shakehand | FL/ST/AN |
| plies | 5-ply all wood | 5W (abachi core + limba) |
| speed | ALL+ | ALL |
| thickness_mm | 5.9mm | 5.8 |
| weight_g | approx 82-85g | 85 |
We may earn a commission from links on this page. Learn more.
Both rate 8.3 and target beginners building technique. Maze Magic is made in Germany at around USD 50, while Appelgren Allplay is Donic’s answer—equally forgiving and versatile.
They share almost identical specs (5-ply all-wood, ALL speed, similar weight/thickness). The real difference: Maze Magic gives you three handle options (AN, FL, ST); Appelgren Allplay is available in FL/ST/AN too, making them equally customizable.
Choose based on brand loyalty and rubber pairing. Maze Magic works with any rubber from day one. Appelgren Allplay shines with quality non-tension rubbers (Hurricane 3, Yasaka Mark V), but high-tension rubber shifts it toward offense and loses its beginner-friendly control edge.
FAQ
Is one significantly faster?
No. Both are ALL speed. Maze Magic scores ALL+, Appelgren Allplay is straight ALL, but the difference is imperceptible for learners.
Which feels better in hand?
Both have medium-soft, enveloping dwell. It comes down to personal preference—Maze Magic’s German build quality may edge Appelgren Allplay, but the latter is similarly consistent.
Can I use any rubber?
Yes on both. Appelgren Allplay’s description emphasizes non-tension rubbers, but it isn’t locked to them. Maze Magic is agnostic and equally forgiving.
Which is the better value?
Maze Magic at around USD 50 is explicitly called outstanding value. Appelgren Allplay is also excellent value but may cost slightly more; either is worth the price for a learner.